← All posts

Why loyalty members don't redeem their points (and 5 ways to fix it)

· 4 min read

You set up a loyalty program, customers are signing up, and points are piling up in their accounts. But hardly anyone is claiming a reward.

That's more common than you'd think, and it matters. A loyalty program only pays off when shoppers use it. Redeeming a reward is what brings a customer back for the next order, so unused points are a sign the program isn't doing its job yet.

The good news: low redemption almost always comes down to a handful of fixable causes.

Why points go unused

When members don't redeem, it's usually one of these:

  • The first reward is too far away. If a shopper needs eight orders to unlock anything, most will forget the program exists long before they get there.
  • They don't know they can afford something. Shoppers rarely check their balance. A reward they could claim today does nothing if they don't know about it.
  • The program is out of sight. If customers only hear about points once, at sign-up, the program fades from memory.
  • The rewards don't appeal. A small discount on a product they don't want isn't worth the effort of claiming.
  • There's no reason to act now. Points that never expire, with no reminders, are easy to put off forever.

Each of these has a simple fix.

1. Make the first reward reachable

The first reward is the most important one in your program. It's where shoppers learn that points are real and worth something.

Price it so that a typical customer can unlock it within one or two orders. A generous sign-up bonus helps too: if new members start with a good chunk of points, their first reward is already close.

You can still offer bigger rewards higher up. Just make sure there's an easy win at the bottom of the ladder.

2. Tell shoppers when a reward is ready

Don't rely on customers to work out what they can afford. Tell them.

The best moments are:

  • Right after they earn points. An email saying "You just earned 120 points, and you now have enough for $10 off" turns a passive balance into a reason to come back.
  • When they visit your store. A small "reward ready" badge on the rewards button catches their eye while they're already shopping.

BizLoop Rewards does both automatically: shoppers get an email when they earn points, and the rewards button shows a badge when they have enough points to claim a reward.

3. Keep the program visible

A loyalty program needs to stay in front of shoppers, not just at sign-up:

  • Keep the rewards button on every page of your store, in your brand colours, so it looks like part of your shop.
  • Mention points on product pages or in your newsletter ("Earn points on every order").
  • Show what each reward costs, so shoppers can see what they're working towards.

The more often customers see their points, the more likely they are to use them.

4. Offer rewards people actually want

If redemptions are low even when shoppers have the points, look at the rewards themselves.

  • Free shipping is one of the most valued rewards there is, because shoppers hate paying for delivery. It often costs you less than an equivalent discount.
  • A fixed amount off ("$10 off your next order") feels more concrete than a small percentage.
  • Rewards on popular products or categories work better than discounts on slow sellers.

Try two or three types of reward and watch which ones get claimed. Keep the winners and drop the rest.

5. Give points a gentle deadline

Points that last forever are easy to ignore. Points that expire after a sensible period, say six or twelve months, give shoppers a reason to act.

The key is to warn them first. A reminder a week or two before points expire ("Your 300 points expire soon. That's enough for free shipping on your next order.") turns a deadline into a nudge back to your store, not a nasty surprise.

BizLoop Rewards sends these reminders for you, and only to members who have enough points to claim a reward, so the email always comes with something they can actually use.

Redemption is where loyalty pays off

Every redeemed reward is a return visit, and often a bigger order than the reward is worth. If your members are sitting on unused points, they're telling you something about your program. Usually it's that the first reward is too far, or they simply don't know what they've earned.

Start with the easy fixes: lower the cost of your first reward, make sure shoppers hear about their points, and set a reasonable expiry with a reminder. Small changes like these are often all it takes to turn a quiet program into one that keeps customers coming back.

More from the blog