Why free shipping makes a great loyalty reward (and how to price it)
· 3 min read
Ask shoppers what stops them finishing an order and shipping costs come up again and again. A product that felt like a good deal suddenly costs more at checkout, and the cart gets abandoned.
That same frustration makes free shipping one of the most effective rewards you can offer in a loyalty program. Here's why it works, how to price it so it pays for itself, and how to set it up.
Why free shipping works so well as a reward
It feels worth more than it costs you. A shopper sees free shipping as removing an annoying extra charge, not as a small discount. If your average shipping is $8, a "$8 off" coupon and a "free shipping" coupon cost you exactly the same, but free shipping usually feels like the better deal.
It's easy to understand. "Free shipping on your next order" needs no maths. Percentage discounts and points-to-dollars conversions make shoppers stop and think. Free shipping doesn't.
It gets used. A reward only builds loyalty if people actually claim it and come back to spend it. Because shipping applies to almost every order, a free-shipping reward is relevant to every customer, not just the ones buying a particular product.
It protects your prices. Unlike a percentage discount, free shipping doesn't touch the price of what you sell. That matters if you don't want customers getting used to paying less for your products.
How to price it
The cost of a free-shipping reward is your shipping cost on that order. To decide how many points it should cost, work out how much a customer needs to spend to earn it.
Say you give 1 point for every $1 spent, and your average shipping cost is $8:
- If the reward costs 150 points, a customer earns it after spending $150. You give back $8 on $150 of sales, about 5%.
- If it costs 100 points, they earn it after $100, about 8% back.
A few guidelines:
- Make the first reward reachable. If your average order is $50, a 150-point reward unlocks on the third order. If it takes ten orders, most customers will never get there.
- Set a minimum order. "Free shipping on orders over $40" stops the reward being used on a tiny order where shipping costs more than your profit. It also nudges customers to add one more item.
- Watch your heaviest shipments. If some products are expensive to ship, a minimum order keeps the reward profitable, or you can pair it with a discount reward instead.
Free shipping or a discount? Offer both
You don't have to choose. Many stores do well with a small ladder of rewards:
- Free shipping, cheap in points and easy to reach
- A fixed discount, such as $10 off, for loyal regulars
- A bigger percentage off, for your very best customers
The free-shipping reward gets customers into the habit of earning and redeeming. The bigger rewards give them a reason to keep going.
How to set it up in BizLoop Rewards
- Open BizLoop Rewards and go to Rewards → Create reward.
- Give it a name, such as "Free shipping".
- Under Discount Type, choose Free shipping.
- Set the cost in points, for example 150.
- Optional: turn on Set a limit for minimum order value and enter your minimum, for example $40.
- Save the reward, then switch it on in your rewards list.
When a customer claims it, they get a single-use code that removes shipping at checkout. The rewards widget on your store shows it alongside your other rewards, with how many points each one needs.
The short version
- Free shipping feels more valuable to customers than a discount of the same cost.
- Price it so customers can reach it within two or three orders.
- Add a minimum order to protect small orders.
- Use it as the first step on a ladder of rewards.
If you haven't added a loyalty program to your store yet, BizLoop Rewards gets you started in a few minutes, with a free 30-day trial.